It is common to hear the phrase ‘a country owes a lot of money’ and imagine a bill that must be paid all at once. Public debt operates in a more complex manner: it is the set of outstanding obligations of the public administration according to the statistical definition used. It includes instruments such as bonds and loans.

Debt and deficit are not synonyms

Deficit is a flow: in a specific period, expenditure exceeds revenue. Debt is a stock: the accumulated obligations still outstanding. A government can have debt even if a single year does not record a deficit; it may also need financing to repay old titles that are maturing.

This final detail explains why a State issues new bonds even when part of the expenditure was already budgeted. Refinancing a maturity means replacing an old obligation with a new one, with terms depending on the market.

Simple example: a budget of 100

Imagine a fictional government that earns 100 million and spends 108 million in a year. The annual deficit is 8 million. If it started with 200 million in debt and no other adjustments occur, it could end up with approximately 208 million. This is a simplification: in real public accounting there are financial operations and adjustments between deficit and debt variation.

If this State pays an average interest rate of 3% on 200 million, the approximate annual cost would be 6 million. However, the real interest depends on maturities, fixed and variable rates, and the maturities of each bond.

What does debt-to-GDP mean?

Comparing only euro debt between two countries is of limited use. The debt-to-GDP ratio relates the outstanding amount to the economy’s annual production. It is not a measure of cash available to the State, but rather a reference to economic scale.

A country with a high debt ratio does not necessarily stop paying; public revenues, growth, institutional credibility, the currency of the debt, and the maturity dates of the securities also matter.

Who ultimately bears the cost?

Debt is repaid through future public resources, refinancing, or other fiscal decisions. Interest payments compete with other budgetary uses. However, it is not accurate to assert that every euro issued today will automatically become an additional euro in taxes tomorrow: the outcome will depend on growth, expenditure, revenues, and financial conditions.

The key idea: to assess the sustainability of debt, look at the cost, the maturity, the ability to generate revenues, and the allocation of expenditure, not just the absolute figure.

A public expenditure can have different effects.

Not all debt issuance implies the same economic consequence. An infrastructure that reduces costs over decades can have a long-term impact different from that of current expenditure, even though both require financing today. This does not mean that the former is always profitable: maintenance costs, actual usage and verifiable benefits must be estimated.

It is also necessary to distinguish the primary balance, which excludes interest, from the total balance. A government can have a primary surplus and, at the same time, a total deficit because interest payments are high. This difference helps to understand why the debt trajectory does not depend only on new expenditure decisions.

No isolated indicator replaces an analysis of payment capacity, maturities and future budgets.

How does a state borrow in practice?

A government that needs funding can issue different debt instruments. Bills typically have shorter maturities; bonds and notes allow raising funds over longer periods. When an investor buys a security, they lend resources to the issuing administration under specific maturity and interest rate conditions. The security can be traded afterwards between investors, so the person who buys it in an auction does not necessarily have to hold it until maturity.

The Treasury defines the auction calendars and the Bank of Spain publishes information on the issuances. However, the essential question of this article is not how to buy debt, but what it implies for public finances. The state can raise funds today and commit to repaying the principal in the future. Meanwhile, it may have to pay interest; the effective cost will depend on the conditions of each issuance and on the state of the markets.

Example: why does a higher interest rate not increase all debt all at once?

Suppose a fictional state with €100,000 million in debt. 80% was issued at a fixed rate and matures gradually over several years; the remaining 20% must be refinanced soon. If the required rate for new issuances rises from 2% to 4%, it should not be concluded that the interest on all €100,000 million will double immediately.

If we imagine, merely to illustrate, that the €20,000 million maturing are refinanced entirely at 4% instead of 2%, the annual difference in interest on that tranche would be €400 million. The other fixed-rate issuances would maintain the agreed conditions until maturity. The total cost will fluctuate as more securities mature or new deficits appear. This difference between market rates and the average cost of debt is fundamental for interpreting news on monetary policy.

Who are the lenders?

Public sector creditors can be banks, investment funds, insurers, households, foreign entities, and central banks, among other agents. Therefore, the phrase ‘we owe the debt to ourselves’ can only be partially true: it depends on who holds the titles and how the income is distributed among them. If the government pays interest to a resident investor, a flow occurs within the economy; if it pays an external creditor, part of the income leaves the country. However, in both cases, resources must be raised or financing obtained to meet the payment.

It is also incorrect to imagine that all taxpayers will literally pay a fixed quota of the debt. Obligations are managed collectively through budgets, taxes, public expenditure, and refinancing. The actual distribution of the cost depends on future political and economic decisions.

The difference between sustainability and debt absence

The fact that a state has debt does not automatically mean it is insolvent. Governments can maintain debt for decades as long as they can finance themselves and meet maturities. Sustainability depends on factors such as economic growth, the interest rate level, revenue collection, the primary budget, and creditor confidence. A high debt-to-GDP ratio raises important questions, but it must be read together with the maturity schedule, the currency of issue, and the state’s institutional capacity.

An example helps to illustrate this. If a country’s debt remains at 100 while its nominal GDP rises from 100 to 110, the ratio falls from approximately 100% to 90.9%, even if the state has not reduced the nominal amount of debt. The opposite can also occur: debt that remains constant can represent a higher relative burden if the economy contracts. The ratio is useful because it relates a financial stock to the economic size, but it does not replace other information.

Why are the current deficit and future debt burden different questions?

There are one-off expenditures that generate long-term obligations and initial investments that can improve future revenues. Building infrastructure may require debt today but have economic effects for many years; covering a recurring current expenditure with debt may have a different justification. However, it is not automatic that a public work pays for itself: maintenance costs, actual users, and social benefits must be examined.

Therefore, when discussing who «will pay» the debt, it is advisable to distinguish between the financial cost, which appears in the budget, and the overall economic impact, which may include public services, activity, and distributional effects. Rigorous debate is not resolved merely by the number of pending millions.

How to read an official Spanish data item

The Bank of Spain explains that debt according to the Excess Deficit Protocol (EDP) is a harmonised indicator for the European monitoring of public finances. Not all liabilities nor all inter-administration relationships are accounted for in the same way. When comparing data between countries or between years, it confirms that the same criteria and the same aggregated administration are being used.

Reference source: Banco de España — What is and how is public debt measured?. Understanding the methodology is as important as the final figure. [Banco de España — Què és i com es mesura el deute públic?]

Sources and complementary reading

  1. https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/001/2024/029/article-A001-en.xml

Photograph: Congreso de los Diputados (España) 01.jpg — Luis García (Zaqarbal) — CC BY-SA 3.0 (resized and converted to WebP).

Educational notice

This content is for educational and informational purposes. It does not constitute financial advice or an investment recommendation.

← Back to all articles